John salza has no idea what hes talking about new feature article this is a devastating expose of salza. John salza responds to the lies, errors and hypocrisy. Quoting directly from todays leading sedevacantist apologists, salza and siscoe reveal how sedevacantists have distorted the teachings of. Jan 11, 2016 the video is a response to the soontobereleased book by john salza and robert siscoe, true or false pope. Autopsy of sspxbacked antisedevacantist book written by john salza and robert siscoe. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors is a recently released 700page book published by angelus press and written by john salza and robert siscoe. It exposes his lies, his massive contradictions, and his errors. Siscoe and salza have been holding out this book as a veritable textbook on anti sedevacantism. A lawyer and former highranking freemason named john salza recently authored an attack on sedevacantism called, the errors of sedevacantism and ecclesiastical law. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza 20150504 mass market paperback 1 jan. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza 20150802. Jan 14, 2016 the video is a response to the soontobereleased book by john salza and robert siscoe, true or false pope. Robert siscoe, a new book on the subject, true or false.
John salza author of the biblical basis for purgatory. After viewing the brief commercial video commercial below, go here to learn how to listen to the show. Every so often someone from the recognizeandresist camp will complain that no sedevacantist has written a full booklength rebuttal of john salza and robert siscoes 700page whopper true or false pope. Siscoes book will surely afford much clarity to the reader. The article provides a unique look at the problems with sedevacantism in.
John salza pope francis robert siscoe sedevacantism team bergoglio from rome info video a handbook for catholic laity on how to convert clergy back to allegiance to pope benedict xvi. However, since november i have been only able to read thus far, 95 pages i read about an hour today from the book. Its not that it isnt a superb book, the title of the book and the length of the book along with a general malaise about anything to do with the current state of the church and the current pope. In this 700 page tome, john salza and robert siscoe present material from popes, ecumenical councils and doctors of the church that. Why traditionalists are not afraid of sedevacantism. The video is a response to the soontobereleased book by john salza and robert siscoe, true or false pope. John salza, remnant convict former traditional catholics. In the first four days of 2016, my video why do traditionalists fear sedevacantism. This doctrine is expounded at length in chapter 12 of the antisedevacantist book, true or false pope. On july 15, 2010, the remnant published my article the errors of sedevacantism and ecclesiastical law. John salza, remnant convict former traditional catholics louie october 23, 2017 155 comments a number of readers have asked me to comment on a recent article written for the remnant by john salza concerning the status of the man known as francis.
John salza is the author of the biblical basis for the catholic faith 4. Discount prices on books by john salza, including titles like the mystery of predestination. This video refutes and exposes the new book written by john salza and robert siscoe on sedevacantism. And between them the last book from john salza siscoe about sedevacantism, the book in short rightly refutes the sedevacantism idea with strong theological arguments, i did not read it myself but had some insights via few friends, they looks happy with the book, any way, in memory of father gruner to whom both had the greatest respect, even if. Discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers new books every 1, 2, or 3 months new customers receive 15% off your.
Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza 20150802 john salza. The article was apparently persuasive for some people. Every so often someone from the recognizeandresist camp will complain that no sedevacantist has written a full book length rebuttal of john salza and robert siscoes 700page whopper true or false pope refuting sedevacantism and other modern. Now available for preorder is a new book, true or false pope. Do you know john salza and his strong refutations against. By john salza and robert siscoe 700 pages a comprehensive and definitive refutation, firmly grounded in ecclesiology, has been sorely needed. They claim sedevacantists wrongly treat certain papal statements of the. This book is for honest truth seekers and must be answered. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors, by john salza and robert siscoe.
Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors, by john. This brilliant refutation of sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza and robert siscoe has done the difficult task remarkably well. John salza, attorney and catholic apologist, who coauthored, with mr. It was featured in the false traditionalist publication, the remnant july 15, 2010. On this page we present a slew of links to articles, blog posts, books, audios, and videos dealing with the subject matter of the papacy, sedevacantism, the false theological position known as recognizebutresist. The remnant newspaper answering a sedevacantist critic. They claim sedevacantists wrongly treat certain papal statements of the past as if they were ex cathedra declarations. Cekada had already analyzed and refuted many of the authors arguments in a june 2015 video, and continued with a series of articles and videos in 2016. A lifelong catholic, john salza was initiated into a wisconsins masonic lodge, lured by the groups camaraderie and philanthropies. The term sedevacantism is derived from the latin phrase sede vacante, which essentially means the seat is vacant. If they are advertising it as a veritable textbook, 2 requires that the book be published with the approbation of competent ecclesiastical authority. More than three years after the release of their book true or false pope. I like john salzas website, scripture catholic and this site is what inspired me to get his book, the biblical basis for the catholic faith. John salza responds to the sedevacantists at however, he have some critics against some vatican ii documents like the definition of religious liberty as a right given by god to worship outside the church or other false gods in dh that depart from what previous popes teach and defined what a right is and other stuff about.
Sedevacantists often fancy themselves as great canonists. Tv interviews robert siscoe and john salza about their. Can you begin by explaining what is meant by this term. Gloria tv interviews john salza and robert siscoe on their book true or false pope. If it were true that no pope has reigned since john xxiii. John salza is an author who has taken on the sedevacantists. It is not the type of book against sedevacantism like those of the patrick madrid crowd which simply beg the question. Jan 06, 2016 gloria tv interviews john salza and robert siscoe on their book true or false pope. This book provides an outstanding treatment of numerous modern errors, each of which are of great importance for us to comprehend at this time of crisis in the church. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza 20150504 john salza. Pontrello addresses the vatican ii problem at a time when the divisions among traditionalists and modernists is reaching a climax.
See all books authored by john salza, including masonry unmasked. John salza has authored a number of books, two of which deal with freemasonry. A big nothingburger from john salza and robert siscoe. True or false pope refuting sedevacantism and other modern. In response to a crisis that pits catholics against catholics the author dismantles the sedevacantist arguments and proves that this movement is just another. Maybe its just me but i think the book is a bit much. John salzas arguments against sedevacantism crushed. John salzas errors on sedevacantism part 1 youtube.
Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors, by john salza and robert siscoe, 700 pages true or false pope. And between them the last book from john salzasiscoe about sedevacantism, the book in short rightly refutes the sedevacantism idea with strong theological arguments, i did not read it myself but had some insights via few friends, they looks happy with the book, any way, in memory of father gruner to whom both had the greatest respect, even if. Michael lofton interviews john salza on sedevacantism. Nov 19, 20 refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza and robert siscoe.
Jan 06, 2016 in the first four days of 2016, my video why do traditionalists fear sedevacantism. Against sedevacantism, and other modern errors, which will be out later this year. Aug 22, 2015 this book is for honest truth seekers and must be answered. Interestingly, rather than demonstrating that traditionalists fear sedevacantism, father cekadas remarks suggest that he fears traditionalists critiques of sedevacantism. In this 700 page tome, john salza and robert siscoe present material from popes, ecumenical councils and doctors of the church that you will never find on a sedevacantist website. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza. Heres the link to the full article which completely refutes john salzas recent arti. Another irrelevant argument bouix on the heretical pope. John salzas a catechism on fatima is the most concise yet comprehensive book on the topic of fatima that exists. It also provoked a testy post by john salza and robert siscoe, authors of true or false pope. Very few people are likely to read this antisedevacantist polemic because of its length and dullness. Feb 24, 2008 i like john salza s website, scripture catholic and this site is what inspired me to get his book, the biblical basis for the catholic faith. Again, i know very little of sedevacantism, and im no canon lawyer, so a lot of this is over my head. An insider reveals the secrets of the lodge, and why catholics cannot be masons, and more on.
In this 700 page tome, john salza and robert siscoe present material from popes, ecumenical. Siscoe and salza have been holding out this book as a veritable textbook on antisedevacantism. Sep 22, 2010 heres the link to the full article which completely refutes john salza s recent arti. A refutation of sedevacantism and other modern errors, john salza and robert siscoe are still busy wasting everybodys time on may 14, they posted on their web site an english translation of an. Jun 22, 2016 posts about sedevacantism written by editor. The errors of sedevacantism will be thoroughly addressed in an upcoming book coauthored by myself and john salza, titled. Robert siscoe, a new book on the subject, true or false pope. It completely refutes all of his arguments against sedevacantism. Recently, father anthony cekada released a video entitled why traditionalists fear sedevacantism. Oct 23, 2017 john salza, remnant convict former traditional catholics louie october 23, 2017 155 comments a number of readers have asked me to comment on a recent article written for the remnant by john salza concerning the status of the man known as francis. John salza responds to the lies, errors and hypocrisy of. Theres a fantastic book by john salza and robert siscoe called true or false pope. Refuting sedevacantism and other modern errors book.
Sedevacantism the vacancy of the papal throne since the death of pope pius xii the chair of st. A site about a new book responding to the arguments of sedevacantists as well as a course on ecclesiology. The sedevacantists believe that the church under pope francis is a substantially. Here is a twopart interview he gave to brother andre marie on that topic, which i think is pretty good. John salza books list of books by author john salza. A refutation of sedevacantism and other modern errors by john salza and robert siscoe. Nor is it like those of the salza, siscoe, and ferrara crowd that intentionally confuse, refuse to call a spade a spade, and outright lie. Jan 20, 2016 now available for preorder is a new book, true or false pope. This doctrine is expounded at length in chapter 12 of the monumental antisedevacantist book, true or false pope. As remarked by bishop fellay in his foreword for this new title. To those trained in scholastic philosophy and desirous of getting an answer to this neodocetism, this book may be an eye opener.